Federal Budget

Sen. Pat Toomey on Fox News Sunday

Mr. Andrew Roth - November 14th, 2011

Sen. Pat Toomey Questions CBO Director Doug Elmendorf

Mr. Andrew Roth - October 28th, 2011

Hey UAW: How about paying back the $15 billion first?

David Keating - September 22nd, 2011

Mickey Kaus asks a great question about the UAW’s new agreement with GM and makes some great observations:

I’m sure there are sophisticated arguments for why the UAW members shouldn’t pay back the taxpayers who bailed their employer out of bankruptcy before they negotiate a deal that gives them each a $5,000 bonus. I just can’t think of them right now. … Just from a PR standpoint, repaying the debt would seem like a good idea…


It’s one thing to give workers power to negotiate above-market wages through collective bargaining–hey, let them squeeze the bosses for all the bosses can bear. It’s another thing when they squeeze more than the bosses can bear, the bosses go broke, and ordinary citizens, many poorer than UAW members, have to make up the difference.  After that, why let the UAW continue to extract Wagner Act wages as if nothing happened?


Club Letter to Speaker Boehner: Pass the Amash BBA

Mr. Andrew Roth - September 21st, 2011


Earlier today, the Club for Growth sent the following letter to Speaker John Boehner, asking him to put the Amash BBA on the House floor for consideration, as part of the debt limit deal, and to urge its support.

Here is a PDF version of the letter.



The Honorable John Boehner
Speaker of the House
U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, DC 20515

September 21, 2011

Dear Mr. Speaker:

The Budget Control Act of 2011 requires the House and Senate to vote “on passage of a joint resolution proposing a balanced budget amendment to the Constitution” sometime between October 1 and December 31.

This presents Congress with a historic opportunity to send such an amendment to the States for ratification.

Rep. Justin Amash and 28 other representatives have sponsored a version of the amendment (H.J.Res. 73) that has enormous potential to create a consensus that appeals to both parties and a broad range of ideological views. This proposed amendment already has sponsors from a broad ideological spectrum in both parties. Such a consensus would greatly improve the possibility of passage by Congress and ratification by the States.

H.J.Res. 73 would balance the budget over the business cycle. It limits debt by specifying that outlays could not exceed the average revenue of the prior three years, adjusted for growth in population and inflation. It allows for debt beyond the limit in emergencies of any kind if approved by a large supermajority of Congress and the president. The proposal would phase out the deficit over a ten-year period after the amendment is ratified.

This amendment has unique features that appeal to both liberals and conservatives who support constitutional limits on debt. Liberals will appreciate its built-in countercyclical features and that it does not attempt to specify that government should be a certain size. Conservatives will appreciate that the amendment is far less reliant on estimates than other balanced budget amendment proposals and provides incentives for pro-growth policies such as predictable tax and debt burdens and low inflation. Its language is simple and consistent with the principles enumerated by the U.S. Constitution.

Economists Carmen Reinhart of the University of Maryland and Kenneth Rogoff of Harvard looked at debt levels and economic growth during the last 200 years in 44 countries. They concluded “Our main finding is that across both advanced countries and emerging markets, high debt/GDP levels (90 percent and above) are associated with notably lower growth outcomes.”

Our debt levels will soon soar well past those levels. Congress is institutionally incapable of balancing the budget on a regular basis – the books have been balanced just five times in the last 50 years. A key reason is because special interest groups fight hard to protect spending that benefits their constituencies, yet any savings from a cut is spread over 300 million citizens. This creates unequal pressure for more and more spending and debt, far beyond what the nation can afford. Without constitutional limits on debt, special interest politics will literally send us to the poorhouse. H.J. Res. 73 is well suited to countering this institutional bias for excessive debt.

If the leadership plans to comply with the Budget Control Act through scheduling a vote on a Balanced Budget Amendment without a tax and spending limit, then it should support passage of H.J.Res. 73 by the House of Representatives.

A Trap, Not an Opportunity

David Keating - August 30th, 2011

Washington Post columnist Ezra Klein notes the inflation-adjusted yield on Treasuries has turned negative.  Therefore, "it would be foolish not to borrow" more money and have the government make more investments.

He names the usual litany of "investments" the government ought to be making in infrastructure, education and fiddling with tax incentives to boost hiring.

The problem he fails to discuss adequately in the column is that government borrowing right now is heavily tilted to short bonds.  So he is really recommending politicians load up on more debt with a 5-year or 7-year balloon payment.

Now, if we knew we had the money to pay off this debt in 7 years, he’d be right, it would be a no-brainer to borrow the money.

But the fiscal picture doesn’t look too good in seven years. 

What this means is that when the balloon payment comes, we will have a lot more debt.  And it may well be refinanced at an interest rate that won’t be affordable.

Lots of people have lost their homes or cars with balloon payments.  Let’s not bet our nation’s credit on it.

Now in fairness to Klein, he puts in one sentence that says "We should … put in place a firm plan to cut deficits later, once the economy is back on track and investors have other places to put their money."

The problem is that politicians will only take the advice to spend now, with catastrophic results later.