Key Vote Alert – Senate – “No” on Suspension of Rule XVI to Proceed to the Appropriations Minibus

  |  

The Club for Growth urges all Senators to vote NO on suspending Rule XVI to proceed to the Appropriations Minibus. The results of this vote will be included in the Club for Growth Foundation’s 2023 congressional scorecard.

The Club for Growth opposes suspending Rule XVI to proceed to the Appropriations Minibus. Unfortunately, some Senators are trying to make sure the longstanding rules of the Senate do not apply to their big government agenda – while still making everyone else play by the same rules. Senate Standing Rule XVI prohibits members from offering amendments to general appropriations bills, “…to increase an appropriation already contained in the bill, or to add a new item of appropriation…” The Senate minibus, by adding two additional appropriation bills to the underlying text of the Military Construction, Veteran’s Affairs, and Related Appropriations Act as passed by the House, is clearly in violation of this rule. Structure determines behavior, and allowing Senate rules to be broken to advance excessive levels of spending will set the stage for another omnibus spending package. This is an unacceptable and immoral outcome.

The American people deserve relief from the reckless spending policies of liberals in Washington – spending that has supercharged inflation, forced up interest rates, put America on the brink of a devastating recession and expanded annual deficits to more $2 trillion. Further, allowing Senate leadership to bypass longstanding rules to advance higher levels of spending is the first step on the road to an omnibus that pleases only D.C. insiders. Club for Growth urges Senators to use their common sense and stand with the American people by opposing the suspension of Rule XVI to proceed to the Appropriations Minibus Appropriations minibus.


Club for Growth Foundation’s Congressional Scorecard for the 118th Congress provides a comprehensive rating of how well or how poorly each member of Congress supports pro-growth, free-market policies and will be distributed to the public.

Read More

Vote Results

Club Position

No

Required for Majority

1/2

Vote Results

Failed

Vote Number

233

Vote Date

September 20, 2023

Vote Counts

YEAs:

49

NAYs:

48

Not Voting:

3

Name

State

Party

Vote Position

Tammy Baldwin

WI

D

Y

Michael Bennet

CO

D

Y

Richard Blumenthal

CT

D

Y

Cory Booker

NJ

D

A

Sherrod Brown

OH

D

Y

Maria Cantwell

WA

D

Y

Benjamin Cardin

MD

D

Y

Thomas Carper

DE

D

Y

Bob Casey

PA

D

Y

Christopher Coons

DE

D

Y

Catherine Cortez Masto

NV

D

Y

Tammy Duckworth

IL

D

Y

Richard Durbin

IL

D

Y

Dianne Feinstein

CA

D

Y

John Fetterman

PA

D

Y

Kirsten Gillibrand

NY

D

Y

Maggie Hassan

NH

D

Y

Martin Heinrich

NM

D

Y

John Hickenlooper

CO

D

Y

Mazie Hirono

HI

D

Y

Tim Kaine

VA

D

Y

Mark Kelly

AZ

D

Y

Amy Klobuchar

MN

D

Y

Ben Lujan

NM

D

Y

Joe Manchin

WV

D

Y

Edward Markey

MA

D

Y

Robert Menendez

NJ

D

Y

Jeff Merkley

OR

D

Y

Christopher Murphy

CT

D

Y

Patty Murray

WA

D

Y

Thomas Ossoff

GA

D

Y

Alex Padilla

CA

D

Y

Gary Peters

MI

D

Y

Jack Reed

RI

D

Y

Jacky Rosen

NV

D

Y

Brian Schatz

HI

D

Y

Chuck Schumer

NY

D

N

Jeanne Shaheen

NH

D

Y

Tina Smith

MN

D

Y

Debbie Stabenow

MI

D

Y

Jon Tester

MT

D

Y

Chris Van Hollen

MD

D

Y

Mark Warner

VA

D

Y

Raphael Warnock

GA

D

Y

Elizabeth Warren

MA

D

Y

Peter Welch

VT

D

Y

Sheldon Whitehouse

RI

D

Y

Ron Wyden

OR

D

Y

Angus King

ME

I

Y

Bernie Sanders

VT

I

Y

Kyrsten Sinema

AZ

I

Y

John Barrasso

WY

R

N

Marsha Blackburn

TN

R

N

John Boozman

AR

R

N

Mike Braun

IN

R

N

Katie Britt

AL

R

N

Ted Budd

NC

R

N

Shelley Moore Capito

WV

R

N

Bill Cassidy

LA

R

N

Susan Collins

ME

R

N

John Cornyn

TX

R

N

Tom Cotton

AR

R

N

Kevin Cramer

ND

R

N

Mike Crapo

ID

R

N

Ted Cruz

TX

R

N

Steve Daines

MT

R

N

Joni Ernst

IA

R

N

Deb Fischer

NE

R

N

Lindsey Graham

SC

R

N

Chuck Grassley

IA

R

N

Bill Hagerty

TN

R

N

Josh Hawley

MO

R

N

John Hoeven

ND

R

N

Cindy Hyde-Smith

MS

R

N

Ron Johnson

WI

R

N

John Kennedy

LA

R

N

James Lankford

OK

R

N

Mike Lee

UT

R

N

Cynthia Lummis

WY

R

N

Roger Marshall

KS

R

N

Mitch McConnell

KY

R

N

Jerry Moran

KS

R

N

Markwayne Mullin

OK

R

N

Lisa Murkowski

AK

R

A

Rand Paul

KY

R

N

Pete Ricketts

NE

R

N

Jim Risch

ID

R

N

Mitt Romney

UT

R

N

Mike Rounds

SD

R

N

Marco Rubio

FL

R

N

Eric Schmitt

MO

R

N

Tim Scott

SC

R

A

Rick Scott

FL

R

N

Dan Sullivan

AK

R

N

John Thune

SD

R

N

Thom Tillis

NC

R

N

Tommy Tuberville

AL

R

N

J.D. Vance

OH

R

N

Roger Wicker

MS

R

N

Todd Young

IN

R

N

Read More